| Classes | |  Stories  | | Bibliography | | What's New | Publications | Main Menu 

West Coast USA Spiritual Travelogue 2002

 by
Hubbatzin Barry Bub, MD and Rabbi Goldie Milgram, author of

Reclaiming Judaism as a Spiritual Practice, Meaning and Mitzvah, & Make Your Own Bar/Bat Mitzvah

 
Posting #1:
   
As Rosh HaShannah approaches, I'm struggling to break through an inner
silence, a listening for guidance and sense of knowing little or nothing
that will be of consequence in the face of what might be possible to hear
leaning over the fence of fear that arose within since 911. People keep
asking why so long between postings?  Listening, sometimes with equanimity
often with yearning, that is "why."
    We've been busy in fascinating ways. Lifted and drifted like leaves in a
warm breeze of Indian Summer, various e-mails have come inviting us to visit
folks or communities around the world, to hang out, to teach. So much so
that we gave up our apartment facing the World Trade Center site in order to
be fully free to respond and freer of the pervasiveness of the event's
impact in the region.
    I have little residual sense of what we've taught along the way,
hopefully what was needed came through for others. It is the listening that
stands out and what can be heard continually feeds my spirit.
    For twelve days we served as rabbinic-couple in residence on the senior
adult side of the lake of Emanuel Camp in the Berkshires. While leading an
intergenerational bibliodrama on Sarah and Hagar with elder women (ages
75-98 or so) and young girls (ages 9-12), they became radically animated at
discovering a precious level of Torah study so little taught in Hebrew
schools, metaphor. This way of drinking from the deep well of text never
ceases to amaze, I experienced their joy at entering the Flow. Like a
nursing mother, the milk comes and it is not one's own to give. My sense is
of being a vessel refilling and serving as a synapse through which the spark
must travel with as much need as a sperm has to reach the egg.
    One vignette among many, regarding the angel that draws Hagar's
attention to the nearby well. [How did Hagar forget?  She's in the
wilderness of Be'er Sheva, "Seven Wells,"  surely a local would know where
some of the Seven Wells are?] "G*d is the angel, the Listener," one elder
explained, to which she pours her heart out like water when the pain of
being alive is too great. When her pouch is empty, the lament exhausted, she
is ready to lift her head, then what friends have been yearning to offer
from their wells she is able to receive to refill her pouch. Their love is
part of how G*d refills her.
      A young girl, who never had spoken once in the two hours hesitantly reaches
for the microphone. The group is so connected now that a hush falls as they
wait for her. "I am Sarah," she says. "I slipped out of the camp to go to
Hagar. I had no idea the huge hole that would appear in our lives when I
pushed her and Ishmael out.  I brought her water. We talked. She decided not
to return, that her son needed not to grow up in the shadow of his brother.
I had set in motion a process I was powerless to stop. Was I an angel to
bring her water? No. Just a person doing teshuvah. Or, perhaps one becomes
an angel through the act of teshuvah."
          Have you ever been white water rafting? The river guides learn to
follow "the tongue of the river."  Rocks may fall and alter its course, sand
may move and mass and shape the flow, yet the heart of the flow continues,
even when stones and breadth tickle it to trickling, the tongue of the river
re -groups its momentum and goes on.
        Water themes permeate this year for Barry and I by choice. After
senior camp  we moved one hour over to Elat Chayyim to teach a week of
Jewish Meditation Walks in Nature. After years of studies in the barns and
yurts there, we resolved last year to create courses that would take us and
our students off campus into the vast, exquisite nature of the Catskill
region. This year we decided to immerse in the study and contemplative theme
of "water" in Judaism.  Beside streams and rivers, under waterfalls and in
water holes we frolicked and studied, gazed, and wondered and glimpsed the
image of "The King" in the mirror of such glory. We're invited back to lead
a Jewish nature walk weekend there this November;  we've named our class "As
Autumn Leaves."
       Tears have been flowing freely, mostly in joy. My oldest son Adam
started college this year, Vassar. In a new trend we're speaking every day,
delightful to hear his progress in a new place. He tells me the orientation
included important facts like the campus is "clothing optional" and that so
long as sex is consensual, it can be held anywhere without fear of
intervention. My sixteen year old Mark is learning how to rally forces
against administrative tyranny in his public high school.  That's my boy!
And my step-children and our grandchildren through them are multiplying and
thriving, thank G*d.
      I take a limited number of private life cycle event assignments, and
one in preparation is a very deep, poetic young man whose parents are
maximally involved in the process. Such a joy for me as  his family to joins
him around the table of study and reflection. Studying with a male orthodox
rabbi, he decided to add a woman rabbi to the mix of his experience. Imagine
taking the idea from a Torah portion of  "nedivat lev" [generousity of
heart] and transforming it into an aliyah at the Torah for those who have
signed their organ donor cards or wish the spiritual support to do so. So he
has chosen to do.
     I feel a great urgency to continue working on a B-mitzvah [r]evolution,
very current studies now show a direct correlation between alienation from
Judaism and HAVING a bar/bat mitzvah.  My hope is to help infeminate a shift
from  memorization and stuffing in of knowledge, to having this b-mitzvah
season be a source of enduring  meaning and maturation for youth and
families. Have been blessed with congregations in Philadelphia, Parsippany
and Boston areas to  beta test the effort.
      Now we're out west for a few months, our first stop was time with
Barry's brother Jeff, wife Sheila and delightful extended family.  They
offered the height of South African hospitality and I felt my new year
instantly sweetened by coming to know another facet of Barry's huge
world-wide family. 
     A very sensuous environment, California. The Huntingdon Library Gardens
range some 200 acres, with more South African species than we saw in any one
place in South Africa itself.  The patterns in the cacti and pre-historic
plantings in opulence were entrancing, the docents rich in detail we would
have overlooked. Then at the Getty Museum for a second time in several
years, the newly planted gardens were stunning in different, geometric,
state of the art architectural ways that we hadn't caught on to before.
     The richly spirited P'nai Or community in Long Beach California invited
us to teach a four hour workshop on Teshuvah. What an experience! My
hubbatzin Barry - psychotherapist/chaplain/intellect and me -
rebbe/intuitive/stickler for knowing the tradition - studied and then
wrestled for months about how to create this experience for their group. Out
of this, of course, came our own opportunities for teshuvah. We became clear
that our beloved friend/mentor/teacher, Dr. Gene Gendlin, who created the
form of listening within known as Focusing, has found the missing nugget of
teshuvah, which might be termed as the skill to gently, supportively allow
the soft voice of G*d to be heard out from under a plethora inner voices
built up on the path of life. Hearing this voice - whether as a feeling, a
symbol, a voice, etc. - and listening to it, dialoguing with it, yields a
turning within which ultimately allows us to turn a new face to the world.
We fou nd examples within Judaism of a similar sense and the combination
with a dash of dance, a solid measure of chant, and a twist of Yiddish
Teshuvah folk music, baked into what one participant sweetly termed "one
hallah of an afternoon."
   Yesterday was a perfect day. With one of our gracious, vivacious local
hosts, Steve Braveman, we wandered from picture perfect Monterey to Esalen
to prepare for leading Rosh HaShannah services and retreat there. At the
River Inn in the mountains of Big Sur we paused to take in a river with
chairs built into it, a huge resident pet goose, and splendiferous
reflections. Moving on to Esalen, we found this season to look so different
than Spring - everything is in such richness of blooming and we've been
given what's called The Big House, a program room overlooking the cliffs and
Pacific coast.  Mmmmmmmmm.  
     To our surprise yesterday was a big day at Esalen, they completed and
opened at 5 pm their new natural hot spring baths down by the ocean. A
breathtaking cliff-side perch and of awesome architectural concept, these
very hot tubs crafted of stone and ever-flowing spring water must be the
most beautiful anywhere.  We did a blessing ritual and of course invited the
spirit of Fritz Perls and Timothy Leary to be in attendance!
     Our "vacation" in Monterey has had two focal points, precious mentoring
time with Rabbi Leah Novick, and long walks in nature with Steve and
Michaela. Steve is a national expert on the treatment of male sex offenders
and has a second specialty in preparing people who wish to change their
gender through drugs and/or surgery. We learned many mind-expanding
psychotherapy concepts, tons about sex therapy also lots about some of their
tikkun olam interests - homelessness and sea-otters. Did you know that sea
otters make love free-floating on the water, the male bites onto the
female's snout so he won't fall off.  Beats being a praying mantis.
    The jelly fish exhibit here at the aquarium in Monterey exceeds those
we've seen around the world. Even my love of science fiction hasn't wrought
anything this magnificent, from the microscopic to the giant phosphorescence
of their flowing glory. For me, Rosh HaShannah is about rebirthing optimism
through witnessing how everything is constantly changing, evolving,
innovating in order to thrive in changing circumstances. The grand vision of
Yud Hey Vav Hey, the Jewish conception of G*d as "becoming what it is
becoming" is what we are - beings becoming.
      This is an easy part of the world to fall in love with, one of the big
decisions facing us in the coming year is where to live when we grow up,
where to be of service and how. Daunting, exciting, confusing! A nice thing
launched is a new web site family and non-profit I'm working on with a
talented team of innovators and supporters, ReclaimingJudaism.org   and
Barry has a site coming out soon too, relating to his teachings in physician
wellness, medicine and healing. His work is starting to be recognized by the
AMA and medical educators I'm very proud of his principled persistence and
profound concepts.
       Pacific Grove is the Monarch [ha melekh?] Butterfly capital of the
continent.  It takes four generations for them to complete a cycle of
migration from Canada to South America.  Each generation gives its all on
its segment of the journey.  Some Jewish mystics say this is not the first
time the world was created and that it has gone through several cycles of
creation and destruction on the way to becoming what it is. One blessing for
the New Year might be for each of us trust the rightness of our place and
phase in the cycle of Being.
    Another blessing might come from a version of a parable as is said to
have been told by the Rebbe of Tzanz: "Two people are separately lost in a
forest. One of them had been lost for many days and had no sense of the
right way to get out. Suddenly the other person appeared traveling nearby. A
great joy arose in the first person, finally, there would be someone to show
the correct way out.
  When they came to each other, the first asked, "Traveler, tell me. What is
the best way to go? I have been lost in the forest for many days." The
second answered, "I cannot tell you what is the proper way. I am also lost.
However, one thing I can tell you. The way I have been going you should not
go. It is NOT the correct way. come let us together choose out a new way."
   It is said the rebbe would finish telling this story with tears in his
eyes. He said: "I am not able to tell you anything except this, the way in
which we have been going until now we should not follow any more. This way
is an error. Let us try for ourselves a new way."  Otzar HaChaim
    Others are writing with diverse and eloquent opinions on the times we
live.  Just for today the Tanzer speaks to my existential condition and
perhaps yours, may we all be blessed to find a new way.  

We're enroute after Esalen to Napa, then Yom Kippur in Portland, Oregon, family time in
Seattle and teaching for the AMA in Canada. B'ezrat haShem, perhaps another
posting will be possible along the way.